Click to visit our sponsor:
(Click the banner to visit our sponsor!)
By: George Guttmann
There are a bunch of widely disseminated bits of construction truisms and myths out there. I hear them quite often during my inspection work. Most are oversimplifications, some contain a kernel of truth, and some are just plain wrong!
Here is a collection of some of my favorites. I would be happy to add any of your favorites to this list, just write to george@soundhome.com.
Table of Contents
- The Way They Used To Build
- Load Bearing Walls
- Locating New Bathrooms Next to Existing Ones
- New Windows Will Pay For Themselves
- Keep The Heat Constant
- This Remodel Will Pay For Itself
- Building Codes Are Stupid...
- Permits Are Expensive and Hard To Get
- Estimating Construction Costs
- Construction Surprises
- Chemical Pest Control
- Flat Roofs Leak
- Solar Heating Was a Failed Experiment
|
The Way They Used To Build:
Well, O.K. I agree, there are a few fine old buildings out there with great woodwork, over sized framing members and great bathroom tile installed on a concrete base. But, when it comes to electrical, plumbing or heating systems, foundations, seismic stability, drywall (vs. lath and plaster), windows (which actually open and close), insulation, etc... I think you get my point. With very few exceptions, most modern construction materials, codes and practices are superior to "the way they used to do it." Besides, I think we judge "the way they..." on the buildings still standing. And the best examples of those have new electrical, plumbing, etc. which cost a great deal more to install than a similar system in a new construction. |
|
Load Bearing Walls:
One of the advantages of wood frame construction (the vast majority of single residential construction) is the ease with which one can alter or eliminate a load bearing wall. Your contractor will need to know what he/she is doing. It might even be necessary to have some engineering calculations to figure out the size of the beam needed for the job. But in terms of the total cost of the job, the cost of such structural alterations is likely to be less than the cost of the electrical components of the project. |
|
Locating New Bathrooms Next to Existing Ones:
The sad truth is that a new simple bathroom will most likely cost a MINIMUM of $8,000, and could cost many times that. The additional cost of plumbing the bathroom, where you actually would like to have it, may add 10% to the total cost of the project. But having it in the right place would seem to me to be well worth that This bit of shortsighted wisdom leads to some funny basement bathrooms. I am thinking of the ones with the toilet on a pedestal, a real throne. |
|
New Windows Will Pay For Themselves:
I am a great fan of energy efficient construction, and have purchased some of the most efficient glazing systems for my home and cabin, but retro-fitting windows is a very expensive proposition, and unlikely to create an investment return equal to a passbook savings account rate.
The bottom line: New windows may have all sorts of advantages but they are unlikely to "pay for themselves". See: A Field Guide To Bad Home Repair and Remodeling Contracts |
|
Keep The Heat Constant:
This one is almost always wrong. With the exception of some kinds of heat pumps, it is always a good idea to adjust the heating or cooling temperatures to the current needs. Setback thermostats are one of the few energy saving devices which will likely pay for themselves in one year. By the way, houses need some heat, so it's best to set the lower temperature setting to between 50 and 55 degrees. ...and for some tips to reduce your cooling needs, see: Air Conditioning |
|
This Remodel Will Pay For Itself:
There are some folks out there who make their living as speculative remodelers. They are very careful in which houses they buy, and what exactly will be worth doing to those structures. But speculative remodeling is not for the amateur or the faint hearted. Most remodeling projects don't increase the value of a house by an amount equal to the cost of the work. The primary reason to remodel a house is for your own use and pleasure. See: A Building and Remodeling Checklist. And what should you do in preparation for the sale of the house:
|
|
Building Codes Are Stupid...:
I recall a conversation with a city fire chief a few years ago, he had a problem recruiting "fire fighters." In his suburban town, the occurrence of home fires was down and this was largely due to the superior construction methods, materials, and codes. As a result, most of the work and training of his staff had very little to do with fires and a lot to do with medical and other emergencies. And, it seems that fighting fires was much more exciting, and a better recruitment tool. What a nice problem to have! There are fewer fires in new construction, and as a result, it is harder to recruit fire fighters. (And, by the way, I wish we had more codes requiring fire sprinkler systems!) New homes also use much less fuel for heating and cooling; require fewer plumbing repairs; and are less likely to be built in a swamp. And most of that is due to those "stupid" codes. Codes are not fun to follow. They don't often allow for special circumstances or innovative approaches. Codes are slow to change. And yes, codes contain some "stupid" provisions. |
|
Permits Are Expensive and Hard To Get:
This is true some of the time. Some complicated project permits may take years and cost thousands of dollars, others will never receive a permit. For example:
However, in most cases getting a new construction or remodeling permit is not a major problem. Proper Planning usually allows for the permit Application Process to proceed along with the design, planing and bidding process. The costs of permits can be quite high in areas where a development tax/fee is added to a new construction application (these are intended to pay for the new services required by the new construction - roads schools etc.). In remodeling, the permit fees are usually less than 1% of the project cost. Electrical, mechanical, and plumbing permits are usually available on the day of application. |
|
Estimating Construction Costs:
Construction estimating and pricing requires a great deal of skill and discipline. It also requires detailed plans and specifications, as well as, a lot of luck. New construction is usually easier to estimate than remodeling since there are fewer surprises to be uncovered when building a structure from scratch. Custom construction with special and unusual details is harder to estimate and price than construction with stock plans and standard details. But, with very few exceptions, it should be possible to develop good estimates and relatively accurate prices for almost all types of construction. Even preliminary estimates require some good information about the proposed project. For example; Will the kitchen remodel require moving a wall? Are the cabinets medium priced prefabricated units? Will the floor be vinyl or ceramic tile? A change to any of these, and many other factors may add thousands of dollars to the project. And yet, it is possible to come up with a realistic budget if some basic assumptions are stated up front. A good construction contract will require good drawings and many details in order to be accurate and complete. |
|
Construction Surprises :
House construction practices tend to follow predictable patterns. For example; the wiring tests and practices found inside the electrical panel, the crawl space and the attic are usually good indications of the quality of wiring to be found inside framing cavities. So, if it seems that all of the "inspectable" wiring was installed by a good quality electrical contractor, then chances are good that the wiring found inside the walls will be of the same quality. Furthermore, it is also very likely that the work performed by the other tradespeople employed by the same general contractor will be of equal and uniform quality. Unfortunately, the opposite conditions are also very predictable. If the wiring inside the panel looks like a rat's nest then chances a quite good that similar disasters are to be expected in other systems installed by the same clan. Quality general contractors choose quality subcontractors. And, quality subcontractors will avoid working with poor quality contractors who fail to select other quality subcontractors. The subcontractor who is hired to install millwork can do a better job in less time if the drywall is even and smooth. The drywall contractor depends on quality framing practices in order to complete the job on time and avoid callbacks for drywall defects which are often largely the result of poor framing practices. The framers want to work on a good foundation, etc... A good home inspection should result in a list of specific findings, as well as, an overall assessment of the construction practices employed when the home was built and during any subsequent remodeling work. This information should help in predicting the level of surprises to be found in the inaccessible areas. See the topic page on The Sound Inspection. |
|
Chemical Pest Control:
With few exceptions, pest control requires some modification to the conducive conditions which attracted the pests in the first place. For example; untreated wood in contact with soil is an invitation for wood destroying organisms. Rat poisons and traps are unlikely to control a rat problem in an area with a lot of debris and with accessible places to build nests. "Better living through chemistry" may be part of the answer to a pest problem, but it is not likely to be the whole answer. See the Washington Toxics Coalition, a non-profit, member-based organization dedicated to protecting public health and the environment by identifying and promoting alternatives to toxic chemicals. You may also want to look in the bookstore under Healthy Home and Environment for books on pest control issues. |
|
Flat Roofs Leak:
I am often called in to evaluate a leaking flat roof and consider the redesign of the roof to one with a sloped surface. To-date, I have never found such a design to be necessary or cost effective. What I have found in these leaking roofs were signs of multiple poor quality patches using a variety of roofing "goop" all of which was applied in an unprofessional manner. So, based upon my experience, flat roofs leak because they were improperly installed and (even more likely) poorly maintained. While it is undoubtedly true the sloped surfaces shed water more easily than flat surfaces, flat roofs built to standard practices of the trades are reliable and less expensive to build than sloped roofs. Flat roofs do require some greater maintenance than sloped roofs, but their total life cycle costs are still lower than that of sloped roofs. Flat roofs have some disadvantages. They are not ideal in areas of heavy snows. They are more difficult to vent. They usually don't allow for easy access to the attic area. It is also important to understand that most flat roofs and roofing surfaces were not built or designed as decks, i.e. walkable surfaces. See:The Sound Roof and Decks |
|
Solar Heating Was a Failed Experiment:
This one gets me mad! Passive solar Solar Heating and cooling can work in almost any climate and on most lots. It can and does keep many homes warmer during the cold months of the year and cooler during warm periods. In extreme climates it can reduce heating and cooling energy costs and in moderate climates it can eliminate the need for air-conditioning and dramatically reduce heating-fuel consumption. Passive heating and cooling systems are not a 100% solution but they can easily be a 50% solutions. And if we could reduce our heating and cooling fuel use by 50% we could save a lot of $$$ and reduce our dependence on foreign oil. And as long as we are on that subject, we have two cars in the family, a hybrid and a turbo diesel wagon. Both can carry 4-5 people and a bunch of luggage. They both do very well on the roads. The diesel can fueled with bio-diesel. And both cars get 42+ MPG. And as for photovoltaics - the production of electricity from sun-light, just take a look at what the big retailers are doing. I may even have to change my dislike for Walmart. They seem to be moving to the forefront of the industry in this area and will show some dramatic energy savings. See: Air Conditioning, Heating Your Home and Producing Your Own Electricity |


